Home        Log in

I have a confession to make... by Jay Knott (09/21/10)       ⇌ (September 11th. 2001)       

...I don't think 9/11 was an inside job. I don't think it was carried out by the CIA or Mossad. I don't think there were any explosives in WTC7. I think all the talk of the melting point of steel, or the failure of the air force to get involved in 'intercepting' hijacked airplanes is easily refuted. I am tempted to follow Alexander Cockburn, and dismiss the '9/11 Truth Movement' as a disastrous diversion which has helped defeat resistance to war.

http://dissidentvoice.org/2010/09/why-we-love-to-hate-conspiracy-theories-911-truth-as-threat-to-the-intelligentsia/

Here, Denis Rancourt, a 9/11 truther, wonders why people he otherwise admires have 'actively avoided', 'demeaned' and 'ridiculed' the 9/11 skeptics. Denis - I understand quite well why Cockburn et al. have poured scorn on the ideas of David Ray Griffin and the rest of the 9/11 truth industry. It's because they think his ideas are fucking stupid.

Cockburn made a big mistake when he claimed that one of the reasons 9/11 truthers don't believe the official story is they can't believe that 'Arabs' are smart enough to have gotten through US security. This falls into the same trap as the 9/11 truthers themselves - assuming you are right, and then looking for the motives of those who disagree:


"Is such self and projected censorship by star intellectuals only the result of the fear of being mobbed by ridicule? Is asking these questions in public fora so dangerous?" asks Denis


Listen, Denis, I have had the experience of being mobbed by ridicule on the 9/11 whodunnit question - being ridiculed by people with ideas like yours! Worse, I have found many 9/11 truth supporters to be so stuck in the circular logic of conspiracy, they think failure to believe their theory is evidence of something suspicious.

No - most of the 'intelligentsia' (Denis's word)  think there is hardly any chance that the US government was involved in the disaster because, using our brains, basic science, and Occam's razor, we have found that by far the most economical explanation is that bin Laden's organization carried out the attacks without US government knowledge or involvement.

Worse than ridicule is the response of president Obama to the president of Iran's recent remark that September 11th. was an inside job. He described Ahmadinejad's remarks as 'hateful and offensive'. How typical of America's culture of political correctness. I don't care if the 9/11 Truth hypothesis is hateful and offensive, I care whether it is the simplest explanation of the facts. I happen to believe it is not, but I don't attack those who do believe it as hateful.

Home        Log in

Comments
My articles on deliberation.info challenging the 9/11 truth movement (05/28/13) by Jay Knott:

http://www.deliberation.info/how-true-911-truth/



An example of the unscientific nature of conspiracy theories (06/10/11) by Jay Knott: Here is a classic piece of conspiracy theory, snipped from a discussion among Pacifica Forum regulars. It's about how the Federal organisation 'FEMA' is part of a world wide conspiracy to put people in 'camps' in the USA....

Conspiracy theories are common on left and right (05/14/11) by Jay Knott: Here is a sensible article about conspiracy theories on a far-right, racialist website: http://www.toqonline.com/blog/cranks-and-credibility Interestingly, the author makes the same allegation against 9/11 truthers, birthers,...

I left a critical comment on a 9/11 'truth' site - will they allow it? (05/05/11) by Jay Knott: Let's see if it ever gets published... http://aircrap.org/fukushima-and-chernobyl-the-diabolical-nuclear-duo-and-the-alternative/331338/ One of the problems with oppositional movements in the USA is they tend to lack a...

Counterpunch's best response to the 9/11 truth conspiracy mongers (05/04/11) by Jay Knott:

http://www.counterpunch.org/jw11282006.html



Attempt to ban criticisms of Zionist power (12/29/10) by Jay Knott: Here is another example of attempting to rebut facts with feelings - an orthodox Greek priest comes out with a theory of how Zionists control the world. Zionists respond, not by refuting the argument factually, but by labeling...

Aussie trade union leader whinges about so-called 9/11 cover-up (10/28/10) by Jay Knott:

http://mycatbirdseat.com/2010/10/aussie-trades-unionist-exposes-911-cover-up/



A classic example of the circular logic of the 9/11 truthers (10/28/10) by Jay Knott: Anthony Hall is a man who is skeptical of the 'official conspiracy theory' of the cause of the events of Sept. 11 2001. He is right to be skeptical - that doesn't mean he is right. http://www.salem-news.com/articles/oc...

Jeff Blankfort on Chomsky and September 11th. (10/24/10) by Jay Knott:

http://www.voltairenet.org/article136002.html