Home        Log in

The 'commie jew' hypothesis by Jay Knott (12/05/12)       ⇌ (Kevin MacDonald)       

Kevin MacDonald's Culture of Critique trilogy contains many profound insights. However, one of its weaknesses is its attempt to revive the idea that the Russian revolution was a Jewish conspiracy. Mostly, MacDonald attempts to falsify his hypotheses, but when it comes to the 'commie jew' hypothesis, he grasps at whatever evidence seems to add evidence.


"Churchill noted the predominance of Jews among Bolshevik leaders (Trotsky, Zinoviev, Litvinoff, Krassin, Radek) and among those responsible for “the system of [state] terrorism.”" (Preface to Culture of Critique, xlv)


This can be falsified by simply noting that, of the three top Bolsheviks, the only Jew got axed.

The Culture of Critique as a PDF file


Here's a comment on an article at deliberation.info by me, summarizing what's useful about MacDonald:


Home        Log in